14 Must-Visit Markets to Assemble your Thanksgiving Meal

Stressed about preparing the perfect Thanksgiving meal? Fear not, we wrote the shopping list for you, and Pennsylvania is a cornucopia just bursting with classic, delicious foodstuffs to grace your table this year! Your family will have full stomachs and big smiles — and leftovers, of course! — from this true farm-to-table feast.

1. Central Market

Shopping List Item: Artisanal Cheeses and Meats

First things first: DYK that Thanksgiving was declared a national holiday in York? So there’s no better way to kick off the full Thanksgiving meal than with a charcuterie tray from Conrad’s Deli at the Central Market in York. You’ll find an impressive selection of artisanal cheeses and meat that will prepare your guests' palettes for the big meal.

2. Lebanon Farmers Market

Shopping List Item: Turkey and Chicken

Lebanon, we think bologna. That’s baloney. Keener Poultry at the Lebanon Farmers Market offers locally grown, free range, and organic turkeys and chickens. Keener has had a home in the market for more than 40 years.

3. Hollabaugh Bros., Inc. Fruit Farm and Market

Shopping List Item: Vegetables

To add some welcome greens and fresh produce to lighten up your Thanksgiving and make it truly farm-to-table, purchase your vegetables at the Hollabaugh Bros., Inc. Fruit Farm and Market. Whether you’re looking for the perfect salad ingredients or need fresh green beans for your casserole, this market will hook you up with local, quality ingredients.

4. Lancaster Central Market

Shopping List Item: Chow Chow or Cranberry Relish

If you’re in search of more sides, swing by Spring Glen Fresh Foods at the Lancaster Central Market. From the PA Dutch specialty chow chow to cranberry relish and others, Spring Glen has a delicious dish for your Thanksgiving table. Don’t forget about your four-legged family members this season; grab a few handmade holiday treats for your favorite furry friend at Lancaster Pet Bakery.

5. Meadville Market House

Shopping List Item: Herbs

Regardless the dish, no flavor is never an option. Swing by the Meadville Market House and pick up (or order online!) some freshly dried or ground herbs, grown naturally at Restoration Herbs.

6. Harvest Valley Farms

Shopping List Item: Fresh Bread

Make your family think you’re the world’s best baker with some fresh bread from Harvest Valley Farms. With classic varieties including ciabatta, focaccia, sourdough, and flavored artisan breads like Italian, potato scallion, sicilian, and garlic, Harvest Valley has it all!

7. Freedom Farms

Shopping List Item: Butter

Bread calls for butter! Freedom Farms in Butler has apple and pumpkin butters that make for a tasty seasonal spread!

8. Bloomfield Saturday Market

Shopping List Item: Spirits

Take in the slew of distinct eateries, bars, pizzerias, and award-winning restaurants and cafes at the Bloomfield Saturday Market. Get your gluten-free fix at Wildrise Bakery. From loaves to rolls to sweet treats, they bake everything with gluten free flours and ingredients. Pick up a roll or three for your meal so that everyone can indulge in your Thanksgiving feast.

9. Easton Public Market

Shopping List Item: Wine

One of the best Thanksgiving pairings is the perfect glass of wine with your dinner. Tolino Vineyards at the Easton Public Market is a family-owned vineyard and winery that grows five varieties of grapes. So, pick up a bottle (or two) of vino to complete your dinner. What’s even better, they now offer curbside pickup!

10. Bird-in-Hand Bakery and Café

Shopping List Item: Pumpkin Pie

Find your (basically required) pumpkin pie at the Bird-in-Hand Bakery and Café which has generations of experience in creating famous pies, especially pumpkin. Or grab a shoo-fly pie to add an extra Pennsylvania Dutch surprise to your feast.

11. Reading Terminal Market

Shopping List Item: Ice Cream

Every Thanksgiving dessert should be ala mode! Good thing Bassetts Ice Cream is available at the Reading Terminal Market. Be adventurous and try their unique flavors, like Matcha Green Tea or the basic vanilla. With more than 40 flavors, America’s oldest ice cream company will have the perfect scoop to pair with your pie this November. Need your ice cream to-go? Bassets has that covered too with their online ordering.

12. Broad Street Market

Shopping List Item: Coffee and Beer

You might need a pick-me-up after filling up on a delicious meal. Pick up coffee beans at Elementary Coffee Co. in the Broad Street Market's stone building to feel refreshed. Or if you need some time to unwind before dessert, stop by the ZeroDay Outpost for a Harrisburg-produced beer to go.

13. Flinchbaughs Orchard and Farm Market

Shopping List Item: Gifts

Missing your family this Thanksgiving? Show them some love by sending them a gift basket from Flinchbaughs Orchard and Farm Market. You can choose from 12 unique baskets and customize with your favorite items, like apple butter and seasonal fruit.

14. Hawley Silk Mill

Shopping List Item: Table Centerpiece

It’s time to set the table! The Hawley Silk Mill has many boutique shops to turn your Thanksgiving tablescape up a notch. Browse decorative home décor where you can find the perfect centerpieces that complement your meal.

For more ideas on where to celebrate Thanksgiving this year, check out the visitPA website. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Instagram to stay up-to-date on even more great ideas and places to visit around our state.

You might also like:   The Ultimate PA-Proud Thanksgiving Guide

share or pin this article

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use our website, we will assume that you are happy to receive all cookies (and milk!) from visitPA.com. Learn more about cookie data in our Privacy Policy